• Russ Cox's avatar
    [release-branch.go1.8] encoding/xml: disable checking of attribute syntax, like Go 1.7 · 02240408
    Russ Cox authored
    Consider this struct, which expects an attribute A and a child C both ints:
    
        type X struct {
            XMLName xml.Name `xml:"X"`
            A       int      `xml:",attr"`
            C       int
        }
    
    Go 1.2 through Go 1.7 were consistent: attributes unchecked,
    children strictly checked:
    
        $ go1.7 run /tmp/x.go
        <X></X>              ok
        <X A=""></X>         ok
        <X A="bad"></X>      ok
        <X></X>              ok
        <X><C></C></X>       ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "": invalid syntax
        <X><C/></X>          ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "": invalid syntax
        <X><C>bad</C></X>    ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "bad": invalid syntax
        $
    
    Go 1.8 made attributes strictly checked, matching children:
    
        $ go1.8 run /tmp/x.go
        <X></X>              ok
        <X A=""></X>         ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "": invalid syntax
        <X A="bad"></X>      ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "bad": invalid syntax
        <X></X>              ok
        <X><C></C></X>       ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "": invalid syntax
        <X><C/></X>          ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "": invalid syntax
        <X><C>bad</C></X>    ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "bad": invalid syntax
        $
    
    but this broke XML code that had empty attributes (#19333).
    
    In Go 1.9 we plan to start allowing empty children (#13417).
    The fix for that will also make empty attributes work again:
    
        $ go run /tmp/x.go  # Go 1.9 development
        <X></X>              ok
        <X A=""></X>         ok
        <X A="bad"></X>      ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "bad": invalid syntax
        <X></X>              ok
        <X><C></C></X>       ok
        <X><C/></X>          ok
        <X><C>bad</C></X>    ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "bad": invalid syntax
        $
    
    For Go 1.8.1, we want to restore the empty attribute behavior
    to match Go 1.7 but not yet change the child behavior as planned for Go 1.9,
    since that change hasn't been through release testing.
    
    Instead, restore the more lax Go 1.7 behavior, so that XML files
    with empty attributes will not be broken until Go 1.9:
    
        $ go run /tmp/x.go  # after this CL
        <X></X>              ok
        <X A=""></X>         ok
        <X A="bad"></X>      ok
        <X></X>              ok
        <X><C></C></X>       ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "": invalid syntax
        <X><C/></X>          ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "": invalid syntax
        <X><C>bad</C></X>    ERROR strconv.ParseInt: parsing "bad": invalid syntax
        $
    
    Fixes #19333.
    
    Change-Id: I3d38ebd2509f5b6ea3fd4856327f887f9a1a8085
    Reviewed-on: https://go-review.googlesource.com/39607
    Run-TryBot: Russ Cox <rsc@golang.org>
    Reviewed-by: 's avatarSarah Adams <shadams@google.com>
    Reviewed-by: 's avatarBrad Fitzpatrick <bradfitz@golang.org>
    TryBot-Result: Gobot Gobot <gobot@golang.org>
    02240408
Name
Last commit
Last update
..
archive Loading commit data...
bufio Loading commit data...
builtin Loading commit data...
bytes Loading commit data...
cmd Loading commit data...
compress Loading commit data...
container Loading commit data...
context Loading commit data...
crypto Loading commit data...
database/sql Loading commit data...
debug Loading commit data...
encoding Loading commit data...
errors Loading commit data...
expvar Loading commit data...
flag Loading commit data...
fmt Loading commit data...
go Loading commit data...
hash Loading commit data...
html Loading commit data...
image Loading commit data...
index/suffixarray Loading commit data...
internal Loading commit data...
io Loading commit data...
log Loading commit data...
math Loading commit data...
mime Loading commit data...
net Loading commit data...
os Loading commit data...
path Loading commit data...
plugin Loading commit data...
reflect Loading commit data...
regexp Loading commit data...
runtime Loading commit data...
sort Loading commit data...
strconv Loading commit data...
strings Loading commit data...
sync Loading commit data...
syscall Loading commit data...
testing Loading commit data...
text Loading commit data...
time Loading commit data...
unicode Loading commit data...
unsafe Loading commit data...
vendor/golang_org/x Loading commit data...
Make.dist Loading commit data...
all.bash Loading commit data...
all.bat Loading commit data...
all.rc Loading commit data...
androidtest.bash Loading commit data...
bootstrap.bash Loading commit data...
buildall.bash Loading commit data...
clean.bash Loading commit data...
clean.bat Loading commit data...
clean.rc Loading commit data...
cmp.bash Loading commit data...
iostest.bash Loading commit data...
make.bash Loading commit data...
make.bat Loading commit data...
make.rc Loading commit data...
naclmake.bash Loading commit data...
nacltest.bash Loading commit data...
race.bash Loading commit data...
race.bat Loading commit data...
run.bash Loading commit data...
run.bat Loading commit data...
run.rc Loading commit data...